Environmental Systems Unit 9: Ethics and Economics
This Environmental Systems unit, Ethics and Economics, has 3 lessons that cover TEKS E.12A, E.12B, E.12C, E.12D, E.12E. Each lesson below gives the goal, key vocabulary, a worked example and practice questions with answers you can check.
Practice this unit with interactive questions
TEKS covered in this unit
- E.12A Evaluate cost-benefit trade-offs of commercial activities such as development, food production, deforestation, mining and energy sources
- E.12B Evaluate economic impacts of individual actions such as overbuilding, habitat destruction, poaching and improper waste disposal
- E.12C Analyze how ethical beliefs influence environmental practices in food production, water distribution, energy production and mineral extraction
- E.12D Discuss how research and technology affect social ethics and legal practices such as building design, recycling and emission standards
- E.12E Argue from evidence whether a healthy economy and a healthy environment are mutually exclusive
Lesson 1: Cost-benefit and economic impacts
TEKS E.12A E.12B
What you will learn
I can evaluate cost-benefit trade-offs of commercial activities such as development, food production, deforestation, mining and energy sources, and economic impacts of individual actions.
I can set out costs and benefits, including hidden costs, in a table.
Key vocabulary
- trade-off
- Giving up some of one thing to gain more of another.
Examples: Jobs vs habitat; Cheap power vs clean air - sustainable development
- Meeting present needs without reducing the ability of future generations to meet theirs.
Examples: Building with green space; Using renewable energy - externality
- A cost or benefit that falls on people not involved in the activity, such as pollution costs.
Examples: Smog from a plant; Clean air from a park
Worked example
A company proposes a lignite coal mine near a Texas town. List costs and benefits and decide what extra information is needed.
- Benefits: 400 jobs, tax income and cheap fuel for the grid.
These are real gains that the town can count in dollars. - Costs: land disturbance, water use and dust, and later air pollution from burning.
Many of these costs fall on neighbors who do not get the jobs. - Hidden cost: reclaiming the mined land costs money after the mine closes.
If no one sets aside money in advance, taxpayers may end up paying. - We need the number of jobs after reclamation, the water used and the health costs.
Without numbers, the comparison is just opinion, because a mine’s long-term effect on the town depends on what remains after the coal is gone.
Strategy: Costs, benefits, who pays
- List the benefits.
- List the costs, including hidden ones.
- Who pays and who gains?
- Decide, and list what data is missing.
Check your understanding
A trade-off means…
- A law
- A free gain
- No cost
- Giving up one thing to gain another
Show the answer
Answer: D. Giving up one thing to gain another
Gain and lose.
An externality is paid by…
- Only buyers
- No one
- Only the company
- People not part of the activity
Show the answer
Answer: D. People not part of the activity
Others pay.
Wetlands provide…
- Only sand
- No services
- Free flood control and filtering
- Higher floods
Show the answer
Answer: C. Free flood control and filtering
They help for free.
Lesson 2: Ethics, research and technology
TEKS E.12C E.12D
What you will learn
I can analyze how ethical beliefs influence environmental practices, and discuss how research and technology affect social ethics and legal practices such as building design, recycling and emission standards.
I can name an ethical view and show how it changes a decision.
Key vocabulary
- environmental ethics
- The study of the moral relationship between humans and the natural world.
Examples: Whether wildlife has value beyond use; Duties to future generations - stewardship
- The belief that people have a responsibility to care for and protect the environment.
Examples: Farmers conserving soil; Land trusts - environmental justice
- The fair treatment of all people regardless of race or income in decisions about environmental laws and policies.
Examples: Neighborhoods near refineries; Equal access to clean water
Worked example
Two views on water distribution in drought: (a) first-come, first-served rights, (b) share cuts equally among users. Explain the ethical values behind each.
- (a) Prior appropriation values earlier investment and certainty for those with older rights.
Farmers who built wells and canals decades ago argue they should not lose water to newcomers. - (b) Equal cuts value fairness and shared sacrifice.
Supporters say everyone depends on water, so everyone should bear the shortage. - Texas uses a mix of both, with cities getting priority for health and safety in extreme drought.
Law often blends ethical views because no single value fits all situations. - Research on actual water use helps people debate with facts instead of just beliefs.
Data on needs and effects shows what each rule would do.
Strategy: Value, decision, evidence
- Name the value.
- Show the decision it leads to.
- Look for evidence.
- Check who bears the cost.
Check your understanding
Stewardship means…
- Selling it
- Owning it only
- Ignoring it
- Caring for the environment
Show the answer
Answer: D. Caring for the environment
Caretaking.
Environmental justice is about…
- Speed
- Secrecy
- Profit
- Fair treatment
Show the answer
Answer: D. Fair treatment
Fairness.
Research affects law by…
- Banning data
- Providing evidence for rules
- Ignoring facts
- Removing laws
Show the answer
Answer: B. Providing evidence for rules
Evidence guides rules.
Lesson 3: Economy and environment: argue from evidence
TEKS E.12E
What you will learn
I can argue from evidence whether a healthy economy and a healthy environment are mutually exclusive.
I can write a claim, evidence and reasoning argument about economy and environment.
Key vocabulary
- claim
- A statement that answers a question and can be supported with evidence.
Examples: Clean air and growth can coexist; A law reduced acid rain - evidence
- Data or observations that support or refute a claim.
Examples: Emission and GDP records; Fish counts - reasoning
- The explanation that links the evidence to the claim.
Examples: Why the numbers support the claim; Mechanism
Worked example
Evidence: from 1970 to 2020 U.S. GDP grew about 270%, while six common air pollutants fell about 78% under the Clean Air Act. Write a claim and reasoning on whether economy and environment are exclusive.
- Claim: A growing economy and cleaner air are not mutually exclusive.
The claim answers the question directly, and a claim must be specific enough that evidence can clearly support or refute it. - Evidence: GDP grew about 270% and pollutant emissions fell about 78% over the same 50 years.
Both numbers cover the same time and country, so the comparison is fair. - Reasoning: regulations pushed companies toward cleaner technology, which became a new industry.
The link between the laws and the drop in emissions explains why both changes happened. - Limits: growth alone did not clean the air, because laws did.
A good argument admits that the result depended on policy, not on growth by itself.
Strategy: Claim, evidence, reasoning
- State a claim.
- Cite numbers.
- Explain the link.
- Admit limits.
Check your understanding
A claim is…
- A rule
- A color
- A guess only
- An answer that can be supported
Show the answer
Answer: D. An answer that can be supported
A supported answer.
Evidence is…
- Hope
- Opinion
- Data supporting the claim
- Rumor
Show the answer
Answer: C. Data supporting the claim
Data.
Reasoning…
- Repeats the claim
- Connects evidence to claim
- Is random
- Ignores data
Show the answer
Answer: B. Connects evidence to claim
It links.