Texas Test Academy

Take learning by the horns.

Environmental Systems Unit 9: Ethics and Economics

This Environmental Systems unit, Ethics and Economics, has 3 lessons that cover TEKS E.12A, E.12B, E.12C, E.12D, E.12E. Each lesson below gives the goal, key vocabulary, a worked example and practice questions with answers you can check.

Practice this unit with interactive questions

TEKS covered in this unit

Lesson 1: Cost-benefit and economic impacts

TEKS E.12A E.12B

What you will learn

I can evaluate cost-benefit trade-offs of commercial activities such as development, food production, deforestation, mining and energy sources, and economic impacts of individual actions.

I can set out costs and benefits, including hidden costs, in a table.

Key vocabulary

trade-off
Giving up some of one thing to gain more of another.
Examples: Jobs vs habitat; Cheap power vs clean air
sustainable development
Meeting present needs without reducing the ability of future generations to meet theirs.
Examples: Building with green space; Using renewable energy
externality
A cost or benefit that falls on people not involved in the activity, such as pollution costs.
Examples: Smog from a plant; Clean air from a park

Worked example

A company proposes a lignite coal mine near a Texas town. List costs and benefits and decide what extra information is needed.

  1. Benefits: 400 jobs, tax income and cheap fuel for the grid.
    These are real gains that the town can count in dollars.
  2. Costs: land disturbance, water use and dust, and later air pollution from burning.
    Many of these costs fall on neighbors who do not get the jobs.
  3. Hidden cost: reclaiming the mined land costs money after the mine closes.
    If no one sets aside money in advance, taxpayers may end up paying.
  4. We need the number of jobs after reclamation, the water used and the health costs.
    Without numbers, the comparison is just opinion, because a mine’s long-term effect on the town depends on what remains after the coal is gone.

Strategy: Costs, benefits, who pays

Check your understanding

  1. A trade-off means…

    1. A law
    2. A free gain
    3. No cost
    4. Giving up one thing to gain another
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Giving up one thing to gain another

    Gain and lose.

  2. An externality is paid by…

    1. Only buyers
    2. No one
    3. Only the company
    4. People not part of the activity
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. People not part of the activity

    Others pay.

  3. Wetlands provide…

    1. Only sand
    2. No services
    3. Free flood control and filtering
    4. Higher floods
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Free flood control and filtering

    They help for free.

Practice this lesson with interactive questions

Lesson 2: Ethics, research and technology

TEKS E.12C E.12D

What you will learn

I can analyze how ethical beliefs influence environmental practices, and discuss how research and technology affect social ethics and legal practices such as building design, recycling and emission standards.

I can name an ethical view and show how it changes a decision.

Key vocabulary

environmental ethics
The study of the moral relationship between humans and the natural world.
Examples: Whether wildlife has value beyond use; Duties to future generations
stewardship
The belief that people have a responsibility to care for and protect the environment.
Examples: Farmers conserving soil; Land trusts
environmental justice
The fair treatment of all people regardless of race or income in decisions about environmental laws and policies.
Examples: Neighborhoods near refineries; Equal access to clean water

Worked example

Two views on water distribution in drought: (a) first-come, first-served rights, (b) share cuts equally among users. Explain the ethical values behind each.

  1. (a) Prior appropriation values earlier investment and certainty for those with older rights.
    Farmers who built wells and canals decades ago argue they should not lose water to newcomers.
  2. (b) Equal cuts value fairness and shared sacrifice.
    Supporters say everyone depends on water, so everyone should bear the shortage.
  3. Texas uses a mix of both, with cities getting priority for health and safety in extreme drought.
    Law often blends ethical views because no single value fits all situations.
  4. Research on actual water use helps people debate with facts instead of just beliefs.
    Data on needs and effects shows what each rule would do.

Strategy: Value, decision, evidence

Check your understanding

  1. Stewardship means…

    1. Selling it
    2. Owning it only
    3. Ignoring it
    4. Caring for the environment
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Caring for the environment

    Caretaking.

  2. Environmental justice is about…

    1. Speed
    2. Secrecy
    3. Profit
    4. Fair treatment
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. Fair treatment

    Fairness.

  3. Research affects law by…

    1. Banning data
    2. Providing evidence for rules
    3. Ignoring facts
    4. Removing laws
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Providing evidence for rules

    Evidence guides rules.

Practice this lesson with interactive questions

Lesson 3: Economy and environment: argue from evidence

TEKS E.12E

What you will learn

I can argue from evidence whether a healthy economy and a healthy environment are mutually exclusive.

I can write a claim, evidence and reasoning argument about economy and environment.

Key vocabulary

claim
A statement that answers a question and can be supported with evidence.
Examples: Clean air and growth can coexist; A law reduced acid rain
evidence
Data or observations that support or refute a claim.
Examples: Emission and GDP records; Fish counts
reasoning
The explanation that links the evidence to the claim.
Examples: Why the numbers support the claim; Mechanism

Worked example

Evidence: from 1970 to 2020 U.S. GDP grew about 270%, while six common air pollutants fell about 78% under the Clean Air Act. Write a claim and reasoning on whether economy and environment are exclusive.

  1. Claim: A growing economy and cleaner air are not mutually exclusive.
    The claim answers the question directly, and a claim must be specific enough that evidence can clearly support or refute it.
  2. Evidence: GDP grew about 270% and pollutant emissions fell about 78% over the same 50 years.
    Both numbers cover the same time and country, so the comparison is fair.
  3. Reasoning: regulations pushed companies toward cleaner technology, which became a new industry.
    The link between the laws and the drop in emissions explains why both changes happened.
  4. Limits: growth alone did not clean the air, because laws did.
    A good argument admits that the result depended on policy, not on growth by itself.

Strategy: Claim, evidence, reasoning

Check your understanding

  1. A claim is…

    1. A rule
    2. A color
    3. A guess only
    4. An answer that can be supported
    Show the answer

    Answer: D. An answer that can be supported

    A supported answer.

  2. Evidence is…

    1. Hope
    2. Opinion
    3. Data supporting the claim
    4. Rumor
    Show the answer

    Answer: C. Data supporting the claim

    Data.

  3. Reasoning…

    1. Repeats the claim
    2. Connects evidence to claim
    3. Is random
    4. Ignores data
    Show the answer

    Answer: B. Connects evidence to claim

    It links.

Practice this lesson with interactive questions